Comments on: Projection, or “Is cello really a solo instrument?”

By: Christina Kim

Christina Kim — Mon, 05 Mar 2007 02:00:56 +0000

I am not a cellist and I have never thought of this matter in the position of a cellist.
I learned a very intersting thing.
To the audience(like me), it is important how much they are moved by a performance.

Anyway, I love cello.
I would love to see your performance!!!!!

By: Alban

Alban — Wed, 28 Feb 2007 07:45:55 +0000

Hi Phillip,

yes, these recordings are unrealistic, and I even find them musically not convincing, since the part of the orchestra is often rather meaningful. How can one record the Dvorak with the orchestra sounding behind the cello? It is more or less a cello symphony.

Doing these rather basic exercises for the left hand is very useful, because you can focus on the left hand without having to worry about the bow and music – I still do it every time I practice (which I will do right now). I had a wonderful time in San Diego, and give your teacher my best regards, I am very flattered!
Alban

By: Phillip

Phillip — Wed, 28 Feb 2007 03:35:48 +0000

Hi Alban,

I played Haydn in C for you in San Diego (not so well). Your advice about my left hand was helpful… the lack of strength in my fingers has always been my biggest problem. I need to practice more to try to correct it. Also, your performance of the Elgar was amazing! My teacher claims you were the first cellist she has heard in San Diego that really moved her.

This problem with cello and projection is truly very frustrating. Of course, I don’t have the same problem having to project over an orchestra (because I never have to, haha). It’s very interesting that you should point out the thing about unfair recording balances… I listen to a lot of recordings and it is absolutely true that CD recordings of cello concertos are very unrealistic. You did a terrific job with the Elgar, though.

Come play in San Diego again sometime soon!

-Phillip